Mastering BBQ: How to Cook Beef Ribs on the Grill with Us

how to cook beef ribs on the grill

Nothing beats the smoky, mouth-watering aroma of perfectly grilled beef ribs. However, achieving that tender, juicy, and flavorful meat can be challenging without the right techniques and tips. That’s why we’re here to help you master the art of grilling beef ribs. Join us as we share our expert knowledge and experience, teaching you how to cook beef ribs on the grill like a pro.

Key Takeaways:

  • Learn grilling techniques for beef ribs to achieve delicious, flavorful results
  • Choose the right cut and quality of beef ribs for best grilling results
  • Properly prepare, season, and marinate your beef ribs before grilling
  • Set up your grill for optimal heat management and smoky flavor
  • Monitor the temperature and doneness of your beef ribs to avoid overcooking or undercooking

How to Cook Beef Ribs on the Grill

Before we jump into the actual grilling, it’s crucial to pick the best beef ribs. Why? Because the quality and cut of your beef rib can greatly impact the end result. For those wondering how to cook beef ribs on the grill, the journey begins much before the grill is fired up. It starts in the aisle of your local butcher shop or supermarket.

raw beef ribs

Choosing the Right Beef Ribs for Grilling

  1. Short Ribs
    • Origin: Lower section of the cow’s chest.
    • Characteristics: Meaty, abundant fat, and bones.
    • Best for: Slow-cooking techniques, like smoking or braising, due to their meatiness.
    • Texture: Tender with a good meat to bone ratio.
  2. Back Ribs
    • Origin: From the backbone, adjacent to the loin section.
    • Characteristics: Leaner than short ribs.
    • Best for: Quick grilling.
    • Texture: Less fatty but retains a juicy, meaty texture.
  3. Plate Ribs
    • Origin: Cow’s belly.
    • Characteristics: Largest beef rib cut.
    • Best for: BBQ lovers! They possess ample marbling which infuses flavor and moisture as it cooks.
    • Texture: The marbling makes them incredibly flavorful and juicy.

Top Tips for Selecting Beef Ribs:

  • Always opt for fresh ribs with a vibrant red color.
  • Look for ribs with white marbling; this promises a juicy outcome!
  • Steer clear from ribs that appear brownish or dried out.
  • For optimal grilling, ribs should measure about 1 to 2 inches in thickness. This ensures they remain moist inside while obtaining a delicious sear outside.

Preparing Your Beef Ribs for Grilling

Now that you’ve selected the best beef ribs, the next step in mastering how to cook beef ribs on the grill is the preparation.

  1. Marination: Marinating your ribs can enhance their flavor. For beef ribs, a mix of olive oil, garlic, rosemary, salt, and pepper can do wonders. Let them marinate for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.
  2. Room Temperature: Before grilling, let the ribs sit out for about 30 minutes to reach room temperature. This ensures even cooking.
  3. Preheat the Grill: Always start with a hot grill to get that perfect sear.

With these tips in mind, you’re on your way to grilling the perfect beef ribs. Remember, the journey of how to cook beef ribs on the grill begins with choosing the right cut and ensuring it’s of the best quality. So, arm yourself with this knowledge, and happy grilling!

seasoning beef ribs

Preparing the Beef Ribs for Grilling

To truly nail the art of how to cook beef ribs on the grill, it’s not just about the grilling itself. It’s also about how you prep those luscious slabs of meat. Let’s dive deep into the crucial steps that make all the difference between ‘just okay’ and ‘absolutely succulent’ beef ribs!

To turn out fantastic results each time you grill, here’s a systematic guide:

Trimming the Beef Ribs

Why: Excess fat can lead to unpredictable flare-ups on the grill, risking burnt meat.


  • Lay out the ribs on a cutting board.
  • Using a sharp knife, trim off any excess fat, leaving roughly a quarter-inch layer.
  • This helps maintain flavor while minimizing flare-ups.

Seasoning the Beef Ribs

Why: Proper seasoning ensures a robust and savory taste.


  • Apply a generous amount of your chosen seasoning blend.
  • Make sure to rub it into every nook and cranny of the meat.

Pro-tip: For an infusion of deep flavor, season the night before and let the ribs sit in the fridge to marinate.

Marinating the Beef Ribs

Why: Beyond flavor, a good marinade can tenderize your beef ribs, promising a melt-in-mouth texture.


  • Mix oil (as a fat base), acid (like vinegar or citrus juice for breaking down tough fibers), and spices.
  • Place the ribs in a ziplock bag or glass container and pour in the marinade.
  • Ensure the ribs are well-coated and refrigerate.
  • Marinate for at least 2 hours, but for a gastronomic revelation, go overnight.

Wrapping the Beef Ribs

Why: Retaining moisture is key for succulent ribs. Foil helps achieve this by trapping in those delectable juices.


  • After the marinating process, lay out a large sheet of foil.
  • Place your beef ribs in the center.
  • Tightly wrap them, ensuring no juices can escape.
  • Position the foil packet on the grill, and let the magic happen!

With this in-depth guide, you’re not just grilling; you’re crafting a culinary masterpiece! This is how to cook beef ribs on the grill that your guests will rave about for weeks. Ready, set, grill!

How to Cook Beef Ribs on the Grill: Setting Up the Perfect Grill Environment

Once you’ve meticulously chosen and prepped your beef ribs, the next step in perfecting how to cook beef ribs on the grill is setting up your grill. Your grill’s environment plays a pivotal role in the final outcome. Here’s your step-by-step guide to ensure your beef ribs get the best treatment they deserve:

Setting Up the Grill for Beef Ribs

  1. Type of Grill: Charcoal vs. Gas
    • Charcoal Grill:
      • Pros: Delivers that sought-after smoky flavor, offers flexibility for a two-zone heat setup.
      • Cons: Takes longer to preheat, temperature control can be trickier.
    • Gas Grill:
      • Pros: Consistent and easily adjustable heat source, faster preheat times.
      • Cons: Misses out on the intense smoky flavor of charcoal.
  2. Grill Cleanliness
    • Before even thinking about laying your ribs down, ensure your grill grates are clean. Old debris can interfere with even cooking and introduce off flavors.
  3. Two-Zone Heat Setup
    • Why: It offers the luxury of both direct and indirect cooking.
    • How:
      • On a charcoal grill: Pile the lit charcoal on one half while leaving the other half empty.
      • On a gas grill: Turn on the burners only on one side.
      • Start by searing your beef ribs over the direct heat, and once you’ve achieved a beautiful crust, transfer them to the indirect side to cook through without any flare-ups.
  4. Choice of Grill Grates
    • Cast Iron Grates:
      • Pros: Exceptional heat retention, gives beautiful grill marks.
      • Cons: Requires regular maintenance to prevent rusting.
    • Stainless Steel Grates:
      • Pros: Easy to clean, rust-resistant.
      • Cons: Doesn’t retain heat as well as cast iron.
    • Tip: Whichever you choose, brush some oil over the grates pre-heating to prevent your beef ribs from sticking.
  5. Smoking with Wood Chips
    • Why: Enhance that classic smoky BBQ flavor, especially if you’re using a gas grill.
    • How:
      • Soak your choice of wood chips in water for about an hour.
      • If using a charcoal grill: Scatter them directly over the coals.
      • If on a gas grill: Make a smoking pouch using aluminum foil, fill it with the damp wood chips, and place near the heat source.

Quick Glance: Grilling Technique Pros and Cons

Grilling TechniqueProsCons
CharcoalProvides smoky flavor. Two-zone setup. Easy setup.More effort to preheat. Tricky temperature control.
GasConsistent heat. Easy temp control. Quick preheat.Misses deep smoky flavor.

Armed with this knowledge, you’re not just grilling, you’re setting the stage for a culinary masterpiece. And this is precisely how to cook beef ribs on the grill ensuring they are flavorful, juicy, and irresistibly smoky. Dive in and let the grilling adventures begin!

Mastering the Art of Cooking Beef Ribs on the Grill

Grilling beef ribs to perfection can be the crown jewel of your BBQ sessions. Let’s break down the process so you can become a maestro of the grill when it comes to beef ribs.

Step-by-Step Guide to Grilling the Beef Ribs

  1. Preparation: Ensure your grill, whether charcoal or gas, is free of any old debris. This ensures even heating and reduces any chances of unwanted flare-ups.
  2. Preheat the Grill:
    • Preheat your grill to a medium-high heat. Aim for temperatures between 350°F to 400°F.
    • Tip: If using a charcoal grill, ensure the coals have a thin, white ash layer before placing the ribs.
  3. Placement of Ribs:
    • Position the ribs on the grill bone side down. This protects the meatier side from intense direct heat.
    • Always use tongs or a spatula to handle the ribs. Piercing the meat with forks can let out those precious juices.
  4. First Phase of Grilling:
    • Grill the ribs for about 20 to 30 minutes. Watch for a rich, caramelized crust to form.
    • Pro Tip: Keep the grill lid closed as much as possible to maintain a consistent temperature.
  5. Flipping and Monitoring:
    • Using tongs or a spatula, gently turn the ribs over.
    • Grill for another 20 to 30 minutes.
    • The goal is to reach an internal temperature between 145°F to 165°F. For precise results, invest in a good meat thermometer. Remember to insert it into the meat without touching the bone.
  6. Applying the Sauce:
    • If you’re a fan of saucy ribs, brush your choice of BBQ sauce during the final 5 to 10 minutes of grilling. This ensures the sauce gets infused without burning.
    • Note: Some sauces contain sugars that can burn quickly, so frequent checks are essential.
  7. Rest and Serve:
    • Once off the grill, let the ribs rest for about 5 to 10 minutes. This allows the juices to redistribute, ensuring a moist bite.
    • Carve the ribs and serve with your favorite sides.

Quick Troubleshooting Tips:

  • Ribs charring too quickly? Move them to a cooler part of the grill or reduce the heat.
  • Ribs seem undercooked? Remember, it’s better to cook longer at a lower temperature for tender results.

There you have it! A deep dive into how to cook beef ribs on the grill. While these guidelines provide a solid foundation, grilling is as much an art as it is a science. Play around with these steps, adjust based on your grill’s quirks, and find that sweet spot that delivers the perfect ribs for your taste. Enjoy your grilling adventures!

How to Infuse Authentic Smoky Flavor into Your Grilled Beef Ribs

For many barbecue aficionados, the soul of how to cook beef ribs on the grill lies in that deep, smoky flavor that tingles the taste buds. If you’re aiming to make your grilled beef ribs the talk of the town, it’s vital to get that smoky essence right. Here’s an in-depth guide to ensuring your ribs aren’t just perfectly cooked but also infused with that irresistible smoky aroma.

Wood Chips: The Classic Method

The traditional way to impart smoke flavor to your meats is using wood chips. Here’s how:

  • Selection: Choose from flavors like hickory, mesquite, applewood, or cherry. Each imparts a distinct flavor to the ribs.
  • Preparation: Soak the chips in water for a minimum of one hour. This prevents them from catching fire and ensures they smolder for longer, producing more smoke.
  • Packaging: Wrap the soaked chips in aluminum foil, then punch a few holes in the top. This allows the smoke to escape and envelop your beef ribs.
  • Placement: Set the foil pouch directly onto the charcoal or burner. As the grill heats up, the smoke released infuses the meat.

Ready-to-Use Smoking Pouches: The Hassle-free Way

For those who prefer a more straightforward approach:

  • Convenience: These pouches come pre-filled with wood chips. Just place and grill!
  • Versatility: Available in various wood types, they’re perfect for those wanting to experiment with different smoky flavors without the mess.

Smoky Marinades: Flavor from Within

Marinating your beef ribs in a smoky-flavored concoction can give a double layer of taste:

  • Ingredients: Typical smoky marinades involve garlic, onion powder, a dash of liquid smoke, Worcestershire sauce, and other herbs and spices.
  • Infusion: Let the beef ribs soak in this flavorful mix for a few hours (or overnight for deeper penetration). As they grill, the smoky essence from the marinade couples with the natural flavors of the beef.

The Combo Punch: Merging Methods for Ultimate Flavor

For those who want it all:

  • Blend Techniques: Use the wood chip method while marinating the ribs in a smoky marinade. This combination ensures the smoke flavor comes from both outside and within.
  • Experimentation: The joy of grilling beef ribs lies in trying out different combinations. Perhaps today’s hickory chips with tomorrow’s mesquite marinade?

By familiarizing yourself with these techniques, you elevate the process of how to cook beef ribs on the grill from just another BBQ dish to an art form. Here’s to achieving the pinnacle of grilled beef rib perfection!

finished beef ribs

The Art of Perfecting the Doneness of Grilled Beef Ribs

Understanding how to cook beef ribs on the grill doesn’t just end with placing them on the grate and turning them occasionally. The essence of perfectly grilled ribs lies in achieving the right level of doneness. Here’s your comprehensive guide to ensuring every bite of your beef ribs is nothing short of perfection.

The Meat Thermometer: Your Best Friend

A meat thermometer is an indispensable tool for those serious about grilling:

  • How to Use: Insert the thermometer probe into the thickest part of the beef rib, steering clear of the bone.
  • Temperature Guide:
    • Rare: 190°F – 200°F
    • Optimal: 203°F to 205°F (This is the sweet spot for beef ribs, allowing them to be tender with all the juices intact.)
    • Overdone: Above 210°F

The Poke Test: Trusting Your Senses

Your fingers can be surprisingly insightful:

  • Method: Gently poke the beef rib with your index finger.
  • Interpretation:
    • Soft and Springy: Almost there.
    • Tender with Slight Bounce: Perfect! This indicates a mouth-watering tenderness.
    • Firm and Hard: It needs more time on the grill.

Visual Cues: The Meat and Bone Dance

Sometimes, the beef ribs themselves give away signs of their readiness:

  • Signs to Look For: The meat begins to retract, exposing more of the bone. This “pull-back” is an age-old indicator of doneness.
  • Caution: While this is a reliable sign, always complement it with either the thermometer or poke test for best results.

Experience: The Silent Teacher

Over time, as you continue to perfect the craft of grilling beef ribs, you’ll develop an intuitive sense:

  • Patterns: You’ll notice patterns in cooking times and visual changes that indicate doneness.
  • Adjustments: Recognizing when to adjust heat or shift the ribs to cooler spots on the grill becomes second nature.

Chart for Quick Reference:

Method of TestingRareOptimalOverdone
Poke TestSoft/SpringyTender with Slight BounceFirm/Hard
Visual CueMinimal Pull-backNoticeable Bone ExposureExcessive Retraction

By mastering these methods of monitoring and testing, you’re not just learning how to cook beef ribs on the grill; you’re ascending to the ranks of grill maestros. Enjoy the journey, and more importantly, enjoy those succulent beef ribs!

serving beef ribs

Perfecting the Finishing Touches: Resting and Serving Grilled Beef Ribs

How to cook beef ribs on the grill is an art, and like any masterpiece, it deserves a proper unveiling. The last stages—resting and serving—are just as vital as the grilling process. Let’s delve deeper into these crucial steps that stand between you and a mouthwatering plate of beef ribs.

The Importance of Resting: Patience Pays Off

Imagine spending hours cooking only to ruin the experience by being hasty. Here’s why resting your ribs is non-negotiable:

  • Why Rest? Resting allows the meat’s fibers, which contract from the heat, to relax again. This ensures the juices don’t flow out immediately upon cutting.
  • The Result: Expect juicy, succulent meat that retains its flavorful moisture.

Resting Tips:

  • Transfer to a Board: Use tongs to shift the ribs to a cutting board.
  • Loose Tenting: Cover the beef ribs with aluminum foil, but avoid sealing tightly.
  • Timing: A 10-15 minute rest is optimal for beef ribs.

Carving Like a Pro: Presentation Matters

The beauty of grilled beef ribs is in their rustic appeal. Here’s how to showcase it:

  • Using the Right Knife: A sharp, long-bladed knife will give you clean cuts.
  • Technique: Identify the natural gap between the bones and glide your knife through.

Serving Styles:

  • Individual Ribs: Perfect for parties or barbecues where guests might be mingling.
  • Larger Portions: Ideal for family dinners where ribs can be further broken down at the table.

Accompaniments: Elevating Your Beef Ribs

Grilling beef ribs is only part of the story. What you pair with them completes the meal.

  • Sides:
    • Grilled Corn with a sprinkle of chili powder.
    • Creamy Coleslaw with hints of apple cider vinegar.
    • Fluffy Baked Potatoes with butter and chives.
  • Sauces and Glazes:
    • Classic BBQ: A staple for rib lovers.
    • Garlic Butter: For those who adore a rich and savory touch.
    • Sweet and Spicy Glaze: For the adventurous palates. Think honey with a dash of cayenne.

Quick Sauce Pairing Chart:

Beef Rib TextureSauce Recommendation
Tender and JuicyClassic BBQ
Slightly CrispyGarlic Butter
Charred EdgesSweet and Spicy Glaze

In the grand scheme of how to cook beef ribs on the grill, these final touches may seem minor. Yet, it’s these nuances that elevate your dish from good to unforgettable. Whether you’re a grilling novice or a seasoned pitmaster, always remember: it’s not just about the process; it’s about the experience. Happy grilling and feasting!

Flavorful Sauces and Complementary Sides To Beef Ribs

You’ve aced the art of how to cook beef ribs on the grill, and now it’s time to amplify the flavors and impress your guests further. When it comes to beef ribs, sauces can heighten the flavor profile, while the right side dishes create a wholesome meal. Here’s an extensive guide on whipping up perfect accompaniments for your grilled beef ribs:

Succulent Sauces to Drizzle or Dip

A meticulously grilled beef rib deserves a sauce that complements its flavors. Here are some sauces you can prepare to elevate your ribs:

  1. Barbecue Sauce:
    • Flavor Profile: Sweet, tangy, and smoky.
    • Key Ingredients: Ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, brown sugar, smoked paprika, and apple cider vinegar.
    • Serving Tip: Brush on the ribs during the last few minutes of grilling or serve on the side.
  2. Chimichurri:
    • Flavor Profile: Fresh, herby, and slightly tangy.
    • Key Ingredients: Fresh parsley, cilantro, garlic, olive oil, red wine vinegar, and red pepper flakes.
    • Serving Tip: Drizzle over freshly grilled beef ribs or provide as a dipping sauce.
  3. Hot Sauce:
    • Flavor Profile: Fiery with a sharp tang.
    • Key Ingredients: Hot peppers (like habaneros or jalapeños), vinegar, garlic, and salt.
    • Serving Tip: For those who dare, this is perfect either brushed lightly on the ribs or as a dipping sauce.

Quick Sauce Pairing Guide:

Beef Rib TextureSauce Recommendation
Tender and JuicyBarbecue Sauce
Charred EdgesChimichurri
Deep Smoky FlavorHot Sauce

Satisfying Sides for Your Beef Ribs

With the main course decided, it’s time to think about the supporting cast—those side dishes that offer contrasting or complementary flavors and textures:

  1. Grilled Corn:
    • Preparation: Slather with butter, season with salt, pepper, and a hint of chili powder.
    • Taste Profile: Sweet with a hint of smokiness.
    • Pairing Note: Its natural sweetness counterbalances the rich, smoky flavor of grilled beef ribs.
  2. Baked Beans:
    • Preparation: Slow-cooked beans with a touch of molasses, chunks of bacon, and aromatic spices.
    • Taste Profile: Sweet, tangy, and slightly smoky.
    • Pairing Note: Its hearty nature complements the meatiness of the ribs.
  3. Macaroni and Cheese:
    • Preparation: Creamy cheese blend with perfectly cooked pasta, topped with golden-brown breadcrumbs.
    • Taste Profile: Creamy, cheesy, with a crunchy top.
    • Pairing Note: The creaminess contrasts beautifully with the textured ribs.

Mastering how to cook beef ribs on the grill is a journey, and these sauces and sides are waypoints that enrich the experience. So, the next time you fire up that grill, remember these accompaniments to make your beef rib feast an unforgettable culinary adventure. Happy grilling!

Troubleshooting Common Grilling Issues

Grilling beef ribs can be a bit challenging, especially if you’re new to it. However, don’t worry if you encounter any hiccups; with our expert tips, you’ll be able to troubleshoot common grilling issues and achieve excellent results every time.

Dry Ribs

One of the most common problems when grilling beef ribs is ending up with dry meat. To avoid this issue, make sure to marinate the ribs for at least four hours or overnight. Adding moisture to the meat will ensure that it stays juicy while cooking. Also, try using a meat thermometer to check the internal temperature and remove the ribs from the grill when they reach 145°F.

Excessive Charring

If your beef ribs are burning on the outside while remaining raw on the inside, it’s likely due to excessive charring. To prevent this, move the ribs to a cooler part of the grill or reduce the heat. Basting the ribs with a sauce that contains sugar can also cause them to burn, so wait until the last few minutes of cooking before applying the sauce.


Flare-ups can be dangerous and ruin your beef ribs. If you experience a flare-up, quickly move the ribs to another area of the grill until the flames die down. Also, try trimming the excess fat from the ribs before grilling to reduce the likelihood of flare-ups.

With these expert tips for grilling beef ribs, you’ll be able to troubleshoot any issues that may arise and achieve perfectly delicious results every time. Happy grilling!


Today, we’ve taken you through a step-by-step guide to cooking beef ribs on the grill. From selecting the right cut of meat to monitoring for doneness, we’ve covered everything you need to know to grill up a mouthwatering meal.

By following our expert tips and techniques, you’ll be able to achieve perfectly grilled beef ribs that are packed with flavor and tenderness. And, with our suggestions for flavorful sauces and complementary sides, you’ll have a complete meal that’s sure to impress your family and friends.

So, fire up your grill and put your newfound knowledge to work! With a little practice, you’ll be a BBQ master in no time. Thanks for joining us on this delicious journey, and happy grilling!


How do I choose the right beef ribs for grilling?

When selecting beef ribs for grilling, look for well-marbled cuts with good meat-to-bone ratio. Choose ribs that are thick and evenly shaped for more consistent cooking.

What are the steps to prepare beef ribs for grilling?

To prepare beef ribs for grilling, start by trimming excess fat and membrane. Season the ribs with your favorite rub or marinade, ensuring the flavors penetrate the meat. Allow the ribs to marinate for at least a few hours or overnight for maximum flavor infusion.

How should I set up my grill for cooking beef ribs?

When grilling beef ribs, preheat your grill to medium-high heat. For charcoal grills, arrange the coals for indirect grilling. For gas grills, light one side of the burners and leave the other side off for indirect heat cooking. This setup allows for even cooking and prevents excessive charring.

What grilling techniques should I use for beef ribs?

To grill beef ribs, start by searing them over direct heat for a few minutes on each side to develop a flavorful crust. Then, move the ribs to indirect heat and continue grilling until they reach the desired doneness, flipping occasionally. Basting with marinade or sauce during the last few minutes adds extra flavor.

How can I add smoky flavor to my beef ribs?

To add smoky flavor to beef ribs, you can use wood chips, smoke pouches, or marinades with smoky ingredients like liquid smoke or smoked paprika. Soak wood chips in water, then place them on the hot coals or in a smoker box for gas grills. The smoke infuses into the meat as it cooks.

What are some methods to test for doneness when grilling beef ribs?

To test the doneness of beef ribs, you can use a meat thermometer to ensure they reach an internal temperature of 145°F (63°C) for medium-rare or 160°F (71°C) for medium. Additionally, you can perform a poke test – the meat should feel tender, with slight resistance but not too firm.

Why is resting beef ribs important after grilling?

Resting beef ribs after grilling allows the juices to redistribute throughout the meat, resulting in juicier and more flavorful ribs. Wrap the ribs loosely in foil and let them rest for about 10-15 minutes before carving and serving.

What are some flavorful sauces and sides that pair well with beef ribs?

Beef ribs pair well with a range of sauces such as tangy BBQ sauce, spicy chipotle sauce, or savory garlic butter. As for sides, consider options like creamy coleslaw, cornbread, grilled vegetables, or loaded baked potatoes to complement the rich flavors of the ribs.

How can I troubleshoot common grilling issues when cooking beef ribs?

If you encounter dry ribs, try basting them with a flavorful sauce during the last few minutes of grilling. To avoid excessive charring, monitor the heat and adjust accordingly, and use indirect grilling for longer cooking times. For flare-ups, move the ribs to a cooler part of the grill and control the flames using a spray bottle filled with water.

This article was reviewed and published by Ryan Yates, Culinary Expert with over 15 years of experience in elevated cooking techniques. This process was tested in a working commercial kitchen that Ryan manages as a Professional Chef.

Note: This article was crafted with the primary intent of educating and assisting our readers. We ensure that our content is backed by research and expertise. For more culinary insights, stay tuned to the Authentic Hospitality blog.

We value your feedback! If you found value in this article or have any questions, please subscribe or leave a comment below. Our team, including Ryan Yates, will be more than happy to engage and assist.

Ryan Yates

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *